Short version: an Amazon competitor analysis is a scorecard. Pick the five organic listings on page one for your keyword, score each on the same seven items, and fix the gaps where most of them beat you. It takes an afternoon, needs no paid tool, and ends with a ranked to-do list instead of a folder of screenshots.
Most competitor research stalls because it has no stopping rule. You open ten tabs, notice everything, and change nothing. This teardown has a fixed input (five listings), a fixed scorecard (seven rows) and a fixed output (the three gaps worth closing first). OptimalCentral is software that flags wasted Amazon ad spend, shows your real profit after every Amazon fee, and finds the FBA reimbursements you can claim back; the steps below use free sources first and point to a tool only where it saves real time.
Step 1: Pick the five listings that matter
Search your main keyword on Amazon in a logged-out window, so personalization does not reorder the page. Take the first five organic results. Skip anything marked sponsored: Amazon says Sponsored Products ads can appear at the top of, alongside, or within shopping results, so the first slots on the page are often paid, and a paid listing says little about what ranks on its own.
Write down the keyword, the date and each ASIN. The page changes weekly, so a teardown without a date cannot be compared with the next one. If you have not settled on the keyword yet, start with our Amazon keyword research guide.
Step 2: Score the listings on seven items
Open each ASIN and fill one row per competitor and one for yourself. Use the same definition every time. The table shows the seven items, what to record and what a gap on each usually means.
| Item | What to record | A gap here usually means |
|---|---|---|
| Title | Primary keyword present? Position of that keyword. Length. | You miss the search, or the keyword sits late where shoppers stop reading. See title optimization. |
| Bullets | Number of benefits that name a use case, size or material. Secondary keywords covered. | Shoppers cannot tell why yours differs. See bullet points. |
| Images | Count, and which slots are used: scale, infographic, lifestyle, comparison, packaging. | Click-through and conversion lag. See image requirements. |
| A+ Content | Present or not. Comparison chart or not. | Page lacks answers below the fold. See A+ Content. |
| Price | Shelf price, coupon badge, price per unit. | You may be priced out of the click, or leaving margin on the table. |
| Rating and reviews | Star rating, review count, the top complaint in the 1- and 2-star reviews. | A trust gap you cannot copy-edit away; the complaint list shows what to fix in the product or the copy. |
| Keyword coverage | Which of your target terms appear in title, bullets or A+; which terms they use that you do not. | You are invisible for terms they are indexed for. See reverse ASIN lookup. |
Step 3: Count the gaps
For each item, count how many of the five rivals are ahead of you. The count is the priority. A gap that four or five rivals have closed is table stakes; a gap only one rival has closed may be that rival's quirk.
Keyword: "insulated travel mug". Your listing against five organic rivals:
Images: you have 4; rivals have 7, 7, 6, 6 and 5. Five of five ahead. Gap rank 1.
Title keyword position: yours starts with the brand, then "insulated travel mug" at word 2; four rivals lead with the keyword. Four of five ahead. Gap rank 2.
Price: yours is $24.99; rivals range $19.99 to $29.99, median $24.99. Zero ahead. No action.
Reviews: yours is 4.4 stars from 310; rivals sit at 4.5 to 4.7 with 800 to 3,000 reviews. Five of five ahead, but not a copy fix: the 2-star reviews all mention lids that leak, so the lid goes on the product to-do list.
The example shows why the count matters. Price looked like the obvious lever; the count says it is not. Images and title order are cheap to change this week.
Step 4: Mine their keywords
Read each rival's title, bullets and A+ Content and list the terms they use that you do not. Then run their ASIN through a reverse ASIN lookup. Amazon's own Brand Analytics lists, for each keyword, the top three products tied to that keyword; it is open to a Brand Representative of a brand enrolled in Brand Registry, and a lookup built on it returns the terms where a given ASIN is one of those top three. Our Reverse ASIN tool does that from any ASIN in one step, and you can paste the shortlist into the Rank Tracker to follow your position.
Keep only the terms that fit your product honestly. Copying a term your product does not match lowers conversion and teaches Amazon the wrong thing about your listing.
What a competitor analysis can't tell you
- It cannot show their sales. Amazon does not publish a competitor's units or revenue. Review count and Best Seller Rank are public signals; any sales figure from a tool is an estimate.
- It cannot show their ad spend or targeting. A rival on page one may hold the spot with ads. The listing you are reading is only half of why it sits there.
- A keyword on their page does not prove they rank for it. Placement is a precondition, not a result. Check where anyone actually ranks with a rank tracker.
- Click share is not an organic-versus-paid split. Amazon does not document whether Top Search Terms clicks include sponsored placements, so read the list as directional.
- Five rivals is a sample. A new entrant or a different search phrasing can show a different page one. Re-run with your second-best keyword before you rewrite everything.
- Copying a leader does not copy their reviews, brand or price position. Close gaps you can close; do not mimic what you cannot back.
One-afternoon checklist
- ☐ Logged-out search for your main keyword; five organic ASINs and the date written down
- ☐ Seven-row scorecard filled for each rival and for your own listing
- ☐ Gap count (rivals ahead of you, out of 5) written next to each row
- ☐ Top two complaints from rivals' 1- and 2-star reviews noted for the product or the copy
- ☐ Rival terms you do not use listed, then cut to the ones your product honestly fits
- ☐ Top three gaps scheduled, one change per week so you can see what moved the click-through and conversion numbers
- ☐ Next teardown on the calendar for next quarter
After a change, judge it against your own numbers: click-through, conversion and the listing quality signals you can see. If you want a baseline before you start, run your listing through the listing audit checklist.
Start the keyword step from the competitor's ASIN
Paste a rival's ASIN into Reverse ASIN and see the Amazon search terms where shoppers choose their product, with search rank, click share and conversion share, in a 14-day free trial.
See Reverse ASIN →Part of the series: stage 2 of 5 (Choose the keywords) in our guide to optimizing an Amazon listing. Next: Place keywords in the listing.
Frequently asked questions
What is Amazon competitor analysis?
It is a side-by-side comparison of your listing with the listings that hold page one for your keyword: title, bullets, images, price, rating, review count and keyword coverage. The output is a short list of gaps you can fix, ranked by how many competitors are ahead of you on each.
How many competitors should I analyze?
Five is enough for a first pass: the top organic results for your main keyword, skipping sponsored placements. Fewer than three gives you no pattern to read; more than eight adds rows without changing the gaps.
How do I find a competitor's keywords on Amazon?
Read their title, bullets and A+ Content for the terms they target, then run a reverse ASIN lookup on their ASIN. A reverse ASIN lookup returns the search terms where that product is among the most-clicked results. Treat the list as evidence of what shoppers click, not proof of what the competitor ranks for.
Can I see a competitor's sales on Amazon?
No. Amazon does not publish a competitor's units or revenue. Best Seller Rank and review count are public signals you can track over time, and any sales number from a third-party tool is an estimate.
How often should I repeat a competitor analysis?
Run the full teardown once a quarter and re-check price, rating and review count for your five rivals monthly. Re-run it sooner when a new competitor reaches page one or your own click or conversion rate drops.